Fi Smart Dog Collar Review

by wigdowalkadmin

As our overview of the Whistle Go Discover and Fitbark GPS exercise/monitoring collars (“Serving to You Preserve Monitor,” WDJ December 2020) went to press, we noticed a web based advert for the Fi Good Canine Collar (pronounced “Fie” as in “WiFi”) and determined to overview it, too.

We purchased and commenced testing Fi’s Sequence 1 collar in November 2020 – simply earlier than Fi launched a Sequence 2 collar. Argh! Fi says the Sequence 2 affords an extended battery life, bolstered {hardware} (to handle stories by Sequence 1 customers of D-ring failures), and an upgraded antenna for improved monitoring in distant places. 

Having bought the Sequence 1 collar, and with our overview of its main opponents already in print, we requested Fi in the event that they’d ship us a Sequence 2 for overview. They agreed, however reported that sturdy orders for the product led to a achievement delay. Thus, we weren’t in a position to get our fingers on a Sequence 2 in time for this overview. What follows is our overview of a Sequence 1 collar, together with stories of Sequence 2 enhancements from customers in a Fi person’s group on Fb, in addition to from Fi.


Product Identify
Maker’s Web site
WDJ RatingPrice
Month-to-month Payment
GuaranteeChargingComments, Professionals, Cons

Fi good collar

Ranking: 3 Paws (out of 4)

”A very good product with one or two important flaws.” $149 from Fi
Not obtainable from Amazon

Subscription prices: $99/12 months

30-day free trial for monitoring; afterward, a subscription is required.Costs by way of a small base unit.

Cost for “homebody canines” stated to final so long as 3 months. In our take a look at, it took 7 weeks of twice-daily canine walks plus occasional different adventures to attract simply 60% of the battery’s cost.Issues we like: The battery life is spectacular. The 30-day free trial and skill to make use of the collar to trace bodily exercise even with out a GPS subscription are good options. We loved the flexibility to see the precise route traveled throughout a stroll (much like human health apps). The social media neighborhood and rating options of the app are a pleasant contact.

Issues we dislike: Reporting occasional automotive rides as walks is a irritating difficulty we hope Fi finds a approach to repair. The scale of the system means it’s seemingly too huge for a lot of toy breeds. The system can solely be used with Fi-compatible collars.


More often than not, the Fi gathers location info by way of Bluetooth from the included base unit or from a related cell system, quite than always looking for GPS factors, which quickly consumes the battery cost. When the “lost-dog” mode is engaged, Fi makes use of three constellations of satellites mixed with AT&T’s LTE-M community protection to triangulate place and ship information to the person by way of a mobile-device app.The Fi app stories the gap traveled, steps taken by your canine, and time take to stroll your canine.


Whereas the beforehand reviewed Whistle Go Discover and FitBark GPS trackers are designed to connect to a canine’s present collar, the Fi Good Collar is constructed right into a customized collar. The monitoring system itself may be faraway from this collar, however it may be used solely on Fi-compatible collars. General, the Fi is sleeker than the boxy Whistle and FitBark trackers.

The monitoring system is in regards to the measurement of a Matchbox toy automotive and is product of brushed metal and black plastic. A skinny stripe within the center capabilities as a light-weight bar that’s managed by the app. The Fi Good Collar is available in 4 sizes (S, M, L, and XL); the smallest Fi suits a neck circumference as small as 111/2 inches (and isn’t really useful for tiny breeds). 

The Fi Good Collar sells for $149. GPS monitoring is free for the primary 30 days; after that, GPS service plans begin at $99 for one 12 months with minor reductions on multi-year plans. In contrast to the opposite units we examined, Fi will file and report the canine’s bodily exercise (not location) with out a paid service plan. 


To make use of the collar, obtain the Fi app, create a profile to your canine, and designate his or her “secure zones.” Distinctive to Fi is the usage of a small base unit that doubles as a charger and connects to the tracker utilizing Bluetooth Low Power (BLE) know-how. The benefit, says a Fi consultant, is that when the tracker is related to a base unit or related cell system, it doesn’t have to entry GPS location information by way of the tracker, which improves general battery efficiency. A reported enchancment to the Sequence 2 collar is WiFi integration, stated to supply longer battery life when away from the bottom or cell system, higher sign protection, and sooner, extra dependable escape detection. 

We like how the monitoring unit magnetically attaches to the bottom/charger, and the tracker expenses rapidly. Make sure you have a back-up collar with ID tags readily available when charging the Fi Good Collar for the reason that all-in-one system have to be eliminated, leaving the canine with out a collar. 


Fi estimates a totally charged battery will last as long as three months for canines who’re at all times residence, as much as two months on canines who go away the home for day by day neighborhood walks, and as much as three weeks on particularly lively canines who spend loads of time away from residence in conditions the place the collar won’t preserve a dependable Bluetooth connection to the bottom unit or proprietor’s cell system. 

Our assessments verify that these estimates are usually not overstated. When test-dog Saber stayed residence in the course of the workweek however joined me on twice-daily walks and occasional weekend mountain climbing excursions, the Fi nonetheless had greater than 40 % of its battery cost after seven weeks. Spectacular! And the WiFi integration on the Sequence 2 collar is claimed to provide even higher general battery life.

Fi claims the battery will final for as much as two days in “misplaced canine mode,” the place it’s counting on GPS to refresh the canine’s location each minute. That is essential, as any tracker is ineffective with a lifeless battery. Nevertheless, “as much as two days” means when beginning with a totally charged battery. When utilizing any monitoring system on a canine escape artist, carefully monitor the battery to maintain it absolutely charged.


The Fi Good Collar is waterproof and saltwater spray resistant. It’s additionally designed with an armored aluminum face plate and bolstered inside steel armor to assist shield in opposition to gnashing tooth throughout bitey-face play.


The Fi app makes use of an algorithm to measure steps taken in addition to miles traveled. In our take a look at, Saber’s reported step depend was persistently near double that of my steps, as reported by my FitBit.

Exercise is reported in three classes: Time spent and steps taken in a chosen secure zone; time spent, steps taken, and distance traveled on a stroll; and time spent and steps taken throughout play. Actions are reported chronologically all through the day, with a map displaying the exercise’s location – together with the total route taken on a stroll, much like train apps comparable to RunKeeper or MapMyRun. 

The Fi app additionally affords enjoyable neighborhood options comparable to picture sharing with different Fi customers, in addition to exercise rankings together with general, by breed, and inside your state and metropolis. I’ll admit that once I got down to stroll twice a day, it was enjoyable to observe Saber’s rank climb to the highest 15% of all Fi-wearing canines.


We simulated a misplaced canine situation by asking a neighbor to take Saber on a stroll. I watched Saber go away and waited for notification that he’d left the secure zone – which took a full three minutes. Fi claims on its web site that it supplies “the quickest, most correct approach to be notified when your canine escapes.” We discovered it to be sooner than the FitBark, however not practically as quick because the Whistle Go Discover, which prompted an alert on the cellphone app inside one minute of Saber’s “escape.”

Escape detection is claimed to be one other space of enchancment with the Sequence 2 Fi Good Collar. Observe that location monitoring could also be slower in landscapes which might be densely constructed up, in addition to distant areas with restricted mobile protection. 

As soon as I acquired an alert that Saber had left a “secure zone” I activated the Fi’s “misplaced canine” mode, triggering GPS-based location updates each 60 seconds. Its location info was extraordinarily correct. I simply discovered Saber strolling with my neighbor about two blocks away from residence. 

One irritating difficulty is the frequency with which Fi registers automotive rides as walks. Saber could be quick, however he undoubtedly by no means walks at 65 miles per hour! Fi’s tech help suggested holding the app open within the background all through the day to scale back these inaccurate stories. It undoubtedly helped, but it surely additionally appeared to attract a major quantity of my cellphone’s battery. Fi is conscious of this difficulty and says it’s working to resolve this with future app updates.


No know-how is ideal, which is why no GPS tracker must be an alternative to good fences and coaching a stable recall. Whereas the Whistle and FitBark merchandise we reviewed mix GPS monitoring capabilities with quite a lot of well being and exercise insights, Fi says its tracker is designed in the beginning to be a lost-dog system that offers house owners the perfect probability of being reunited with their canines. Primarily based on battery life alone, this declare feels stable – since no GPS tracker can overcome a prematurely lifeless battery. 

The put up Fi Good Canine Collar Evaluate appeared first on Complete Canine Journal.

Source link

You may also like

Leave a Comment